It all started with a low-expectation Tinder date at Cowboy Jack’s in July 2021—and somehow turned into more laughter than either of them saw coming. One move-in, two cats, countless Chili’s dates, and an alarming number of golf swings later, it was clear the adventure had only just begun.

Simon proposed to AmyJo on a sunny March day in Siesta Key, Florida. He pictured a quiet, private moment like in the movies… but instead, fate provided a full audience of cheering strangers. Amy Jo may have wanted to melt into the sand for a second, but her “yes” was loud enough to earn its own round of applause.